ICOMOS Lebanon Alert on Nahr El Kalb
- November 17, 2026
- ICOMOS Lebanon
- Source
The International Council on Monuments and Sites – Lebanon (ICOMOS Lebanon), representing the national heritage community, expresses its deep concern and its profound sorrow at the construction of a massive concrete base intended to carry a 16-metre flagpole on the promontory of Nahr el-Kalb, in the immediate setting of the commemorative stelae, a site inscribed on UNESCO’s Memory of the World Register since 2005 and on Lebanon’s Tentative List for the World Heritage List since 2019.
For more than two years, the voice of ICOMOS Lebanon has been raised almost exclusively to defend our heritage against destruction by an external enemy: in Tyre, at Beaufort, in Chamaa, in the villages, fields and living traditions of the South. We did not expect to have to raise it, today, against damage that we are inflicting on ourselves, gratuitously, in one of the places that tells most eloquently who we are. We issue this statement with a sense of shame that we believe should be shared by all.
This statement is not written to condemn, nor to apportion blame among institutions and individuals. Its purpose is to recall the basic principles of heritage protection, the legal and professional procedures that exist precisely to prevent situations like this one, and the consequences of what has been done to the site.
I. The Site
Nahr el-Kalb, the ancient Lycus, is the narrow passage where the mountain falls into the sea, 15 km north of Beirut. For more than three thousand years, every power that forced this crossing left its mark on the rock. Some 16 stelae, reliefs and inscriptions – Egyptian, Neo-Assyrian, Neo-Babylonian, Greek, Roman, Mamluk, Ottoman, French, British and Lebanese – in hieroglyphic, cuneiform, Greek, Latin, Arabic, French and English, form together an open-air archive of the history of the region, from Ramesses II in the 13th century BC to the 20th century.
The site is not a collection of isolated inscriptions. Its meaning lies in the relationship between the carved rock, the steep promontory, the river, the sea and the ancient road. It is the difficulty of the passage that gave birth to the stelae; it is the landscape that explains them. Destroy or overpower that landscape, and the stelae become fragments without a context.
The last two inscriptions on the rock are our own (as Lebanese). The first records the evacuation of all foreign troops from Lebanon on 31 December 1946. The second records the liberation of the South on 24 May 2000. The Lebanese State has already written its sovereignty on the rock of Nahr el-Kalb – in stone, in proportion, and in dialogue with thirty centuries of history.
II. What has been done, and what it means
The current project consists of a reinforced concrete base for a 16-metre mast, built on the promontory above the Nahr el-Kalb tunnel, within the immediate setting of the stelae. ICOMOS Lebanon wishes to state clearly: we do not object to the Lebanese flag. We object to the place, the scale and the way in which this project was carried out.
The documents available to us show that:
1. Construction of this same base began a year ago, ahead of Independence Day 2025. The Ministry of Culture – DGA refused the request and issued no permit for the concrete base; it halted the works in November 2025 because of the risks to the historic inscriptions, and no authorisation to resume them was ever issued.
2. In early November 2026, work on the same base resumed without any authorisation from the Ministry of Culture, with the stated aim of completing it before Independence Day on 16 November. On 9 November, the Ministry announced that the Minister had asked the Minister of Interior and Municipalities to intervene immediately to stop them. It recalled that the November 2025 suspension remained in force and that no notice allowing the works to resume had been sent to the Public Prosecution. On 10 November, the Minister asked the Mount Lebanon Appellate Public Prosecutor for a decision halting all works in the archaeological area.
3. The Ministry of Culture set out thirteen conditions for any flagpole project, starting with the removal of the existing concrete base at the expense of the project owner and the rehabilitation of the site, the relocation of the project outside the archaeological site and any legally defined protection zone, and the preparation of a Heritage and Visual Impact Assessment with accurate simulations.
4. The letter of the Ministry of Public Works and Transport is a conditional “no objection”, which itself states that it is subject to all other legally required permits and approvals, does not replace them, and obliges the municipality to preserve the site and its heritage, archaeological and natural elements and to undertake no works affecting them without the approval of the competent authorities.
In other words, no administrative document authorised what was built. The argument that the base stands on a plot that is not itself classified as archaeological does not change this. The protection of a site is not limited to the cadastral plots that carry its inscriptions: the setting is an integral part of their significance, as the principles recalled below make clear.
III. Impact on the Integrity of the site
– The concrete base and the mast introduce a massive, permanent, alien element into the very space that conveys the meaning of the site: the relationship between the rock, the stelae, the river and the sea.
– A 16-metre vertical structure on the promontory competes with, and visually dominates, monuments that were deliberately carved at human scale into the cliff.
– Excavation, anchoring and the loads of a tall mast exposed to wind on a fragile limestone promontory create real risks for the rock and the inscriptions themselves.
– Every intervention of this kind accumulates with the previous encroachments on the promontory and erodes, step by step, the wholeness of the site.
IV. Impact on the authenticity of the site
– Location and setting: the commemorative landscape, whose dramatic topography is the very reason for the stelae, is altered by a structure that has no historical or functional relationship with it.
– Form and design: the relations of scale and mass between the inscriptions and their setting are overturned; the monuments become a foreground for a mast.
– Spirit and feeling: a place of memory, contemplation and reflection on the passage of empires is transformed into a stage for display.
– Meaning: the stelae of Nahr el-Kalb are, in essence, marks of power imposed on the rock. Adding one more mark of domination, out of scale, repeats the gesture of the conquerors instead of inscribing ourselves, as the 1946 and 2000 inscriptions did, in the continuity of the site.
These impacts directly affect the qualities for which the site was placed on the Tentative List under criteria (iii) and (vi), and they weaken Lebanon’s own case for a future World Heritage nomination.
V. The basics we wish to recall
The protection of Nahr el-Kalb does not depend on goodwill. It rests on a legal and professional framework that already exists:
– The Antiquities Regulation (Arrêté No. 166/LR of 1933) and the Ministerial Decision No. 506 of 1937 listing the stelae on the General Inventory of Historic Monuments, which place any intervention affecting them under the authority of the DGA.
– The protection of the Nahr el-Kalb river and its banks as a natural site (1998), and the Environmental Protection Law No. 444/2002 with its EIA Decree No. 8633/2012, which require that projects be screened and assessed before any decision.
– Law No. 251/2014, which assigns dedicated public prosecutors and investigating judges to environmental offences, explicitly including violations of the laws protecting antiquities.
– The World Heritage Convention (1972), under which Lebanon has undertaken to identify, protect, conserve and transmit its heritage to future generations. Placing a site on the Tentative List is a declaration by the State, before the international community, that it considers the site to be of potential Outstanding Universal Value – a declaration that carries a duty of care.
– The Venice Charter (1964), which affirms that a monument is inseparable from its setting and that no new construction which would alter the relations of mass and colour should be allowed.
– The ICOMOS Charter for the Protection and Management of the Archaeological Heritage (1990) and the Nara Document on Authenticity (1994).
– The ICOMOS Xi’an Declaration (2005), which recognises that the setting of a site is the immediate and extended environment that contributes to its significance, and that skylines, sight lines and adequate distance from new development are essential to its protection.
VI. Why Heritage Impact Assessment matters
A Heritage Impact Assessment (HIA) is not a bureaucratic obstacle. It is the tool that allows a society to ask, before acting, the questions that cannot be asked afterwards: what makes this place significant? Which attributes carry that significance? How will the proposed project affect them? Is there another location, another design, another scale that would achieve the same objective without harm?
The UNESCO / ICCROM / ICOMOS / IUCN Guidance and Toolkit for Impact Assessments in a World Heritage Context (2016) sets out the international reference for this process. Applied here, an HIA would very likely have shown that the national purpose of the project could be fully achieved elsewhere, without touching the promontory. This is precisely what the Ministry of Culture requested. An assessment carried out after the concrete has been poured can only measure a loss; an assessment carried out before can prevent it.
VII. Beyond procedure: The heart of the matter
Laws, procedures and charters are necessary. But what happened at Nahr el-Kalb reveals something deeper than an administrative failure.
We live in a time that values the spectacular over the meaningful, the immediate over the lasting, display over substance. We run after flashy gestures, quick excitement and the satisfaction of being seen, and we forget them as quickly as a child forgets yesterday’s toy, already searching for the next one. Heritage is not a backdrop for our achievements, real or imagined, nor a decor to be photographed and then abandoned to the routine of the next day. Its value lies in its serenity, its humility, its patience – in the long time it embodies, which no monument of display can ever replace.
We have lost many of our reference points. We are running in the dark, holding on to any beacon that shines for a moment, until we find another and then another. But the slope is steep, and it leads to the loss of the values that truly anchor us: a sense of history, of culture, of continuity, of belonging. These values are not about tourism or image. They are about who we are.
VIII. ICOMOS Lebanon therefore calls for
1. The full respect of the decisions of the Ministry of Culture and of the judicial authority, and the immediate and complete cessation of all works on the promontory.
2. The removal of the concrete base and the rehabilitation of the site at the expense of the project owner, under the supervision of the DGA, in line with the conditions set by the Ministry of Culture.
3. The relocation of any flagpole project outside the archaeological site and its setting, on the basis of a Heritage and Visual Impact Assessment carried out according to international standards before any decision is taken.
4. The legal delimitation of the site and of a protection (buffer) zone, including the non-aedificandi status of the promontory, as ICOMOS Lebanon and ICAHM already recommended in 2020.
5. Clear coordination among public administrations, so that no approval, “no objection” or permit concerning a listed site or a site on the Tentative List can be issued without the prior written consent of the DGA, and so that Heritage Impact Assessment becomes a systematic part of environmental screening for such sites.
6. The effective enforcement of existing laws, including through the environmental public prosecutors established by Law No. 251/2014.
7. A genuine partnership with municipalities, who are the first guardians of the heritage in their territory. ICOMOS Lebanon stands ready to offer its expertise, free of charge, to help design a dignified alternative that honours both the flag and the site.
| The Lebanese flag deserves to fly high. It does not need to stand on the rock of Nahr el-Kalb to do so; that rock already bears the words of our independence and of our liberation. The most powerful affirmation of sovereignty is not to impose a new mark on our history, but to protect it. |
ICOMOS Lebanon stands firm in its mission to safeguard Lebanon’s heritage – from external destruction and from our own – and calls on all stakeholders to ensure the protection of Nahr el-Kalb before it is too late.
